9.20.2006

(Re)Defining Sin

Ok - I can imagine that the title alone has already raised some red flags for some readers, and rightly so. It's one thing to talk about re-interpreting scripture, re-structuring the Church, etc. But don't mess with sin! I agree. Sin is a serious topic. Hang in a while, and I think you'll see that I treat it just as seriously as any evangelical would. My purpose here is not to reason away the seriousness of sin, but to do it more justice than is traditionally done.

One thing that all Christians should be able to agree on is the centrality of Christ and his teachings. In regards to spiritual law, Christ gave assent to two commands that sum up his view on how sin should be judged: "Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your strength and with all your mind; and love your neighbor as yourself." (Luke 10:27). So often, Christians bring to the "sin discussion" various do's and dont's from throughout scripture. Christ simplified it for us. He gave us a love command to measure what is sinful and what is not. In Mark 12:31, Christ tells us there is no other command that supercedes these two love commands. So how should these words of Christ help us to redefine sin?

  1. Sin is the absence of loving relationship with God and people. Sin is not first and foremost an act of commission, but an act of omission. Sin can be decided based on the lack of presence of love.
  2. Sin is failing to love God, neighbor, and self. Loving God is basically living in the presence of God, or having our being in His Spirit. Loving our neighbor, at least in Luke's gospel, is loving the other (i.e. those we would traditionally have nothing to do with). A lover of neighbors is one who has mercy on the outcast/other (v.37). Loving ourself is first self-identifying with the other, then loving the self. In other words, loving the self is recognizing that we have as much standing in the experience of grace as the person we consider most different from ourself, and that we love ourselves as much as we love the other person. Most Christians get the "love your neighbor as yourself" command backwards, because they start with only loving what is easy to love about themselves. Starting the neighborly love process from the foundation of the other stretches the command to a new, and more difficult level.

Sin, therefore, is not about a list of do's and dont's, but about acts of love toward God, others, and self. Therefore, rather than the person who follows the most rules, the most sanctified Christian is the one who loves the most.

Peace & Blessings.

2 comments:

Danifesto said...

Your #1 reminded me of this prayer we have been saying in Mass where it speaks of omission as a sin-
"I confess to almighty God,
and to you, my brothers and sisters,that I have sinned through my own fault,in my thoughts and in my words,in what I have done,
and in what I have failed to do..."

Your #2- I had a thought though in response to your order- neighbors and then self. Jesus says "Love your neighbor as yourself." The wording (which sometimes reads "as you have loved yourself") implies to me that love of self would therefore have come beforehand.

Perhaps learning to love ourselves and the creations we are allows us to then love all of God's creations as a response? Maybe those who hurt others are doing so because they don't love themselves? Oh I dunno. It's just a thought...

daniel.emerging said...

Your take on number 2 is a good thought, and is how I've traditionally heard the passage interpreted. I do think loving ourselves is an important step to loving others. It seems, though, that taking the extra step to love others first and recognize the "otherness" in ourselves, helps us love ourselves and others more. Just a thought^^

Peace,
Daniel